To do something to instruct, but more to undeceive, the timid and admiring student:--to excite him to place more confidence in his own strength, and less in the infallibility of great names:--to help him to emancipate his judgment from the shackles of authority:--to let him see that the not understanding a discourse may as well be the writer's fault as the reader's:--to teach him to distinguish between shewy language and sound sense:--to warn him not to pay himself with words:--to shew him that what may tickle the ear, or dazzle the imagination, will not always inform the judgment...
--From A Fragment on Government--
Showing posts with label Bentham. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bentham. Show all posts
Sunday, May 31, 2009
Friday, May 29, 2009
Simple truths, 1776 edition
Now and then, it is true, one error may be driven out, for a time, by an opposite error: one piece of nonsense by another piece of nonsense: but for barring the door effectually and for ever against all error and all nonsense, there is nothing like the simple truth.
--From A Fragment on Government--
Sometimes I feel as if simple truths are like a feather blowing in a hurricane. When you find them you have to hold on for dear life.
--From A Fragment on Government--
Sometimes I feel as if simple truths are like a feather blowing in a hurricane. When you find them you have to hold on for dear life.
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
Kindred spirits, 1776 edition
For my part, if ever I stand forth and sing the song of eulogy to great men, it shall be not because they occupy their station, but because they deserve it.
--From A Fragment on Government--
Sometimes you just have to agree completely with what someone else says.
--From A Fragment on Government--
Sometimes you just have to agree completely with what someone else says.
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
A different way of thinking, 1776 edition
...it is their duty to obey, just so long as it is their interest, and no longer.
--From A Fragment on Government--
This is Bentham talking about the social contract, where citizens agree to follow the rules set down by their government so long as their rulers govern well. But we don't seem to talk about our system of government in terms of a social contract anymore. Instead we talk about rights and responsibilities.
Which got me to asking: do rights come with responsibilities, as we are always told? Yes, but I suspect the idea is something of a fraud. When we talk about rights and responsibilities we are only thinking about getting citizens to conform to the rule of law. We never think to question whether the government is fulfilling its obligation to govern well.
It's as if rights are a commodity and responsibilities are the price we have to pay for them. But if someone were to have complete control of a commodity and charge exorbitant prices wouldn't we call that a monopoly and try to break it up?
So, the next time someone says, "rights come with responsibilities," ask yourself if you're being asked to pay too much.
--From A Fragment on Government--
This is Bentham talking about the social contract, where citizens agree to follow the rules set down by their government so long as their rulers govern well. But we don't seem to talk about our system of government in terms of a social contract anymore. Instead we talk about rights and responsibilities.
Which got me to asking: do rights come with responsibilities, as we are always told? Yes, but I suspect the idea is something of a fraud. When we talk about rights and responsibilities we are only thinking about getting citizens to conform to the rule of law. We never think to question whether the government is fulfilling its obligation to govern well.
It's as if rights are a commodity and responsibilities are the price we have to pay for them. But if someone were to have complete control of a commodity and charge exorbitant prices wouldn't we call that a monopoly and try to break it up?
So, the next time someone says, "rights come with responsibilities," ask yourself if you're being asked to pay too much.
Monday, May 25, 2009
Seasons, 1776 edition
...the season of Fiction is now over...
--From A Fragment on Government--
It's not pretty when such a season ends. You don't have people coming to watch the leaves change colors, you have historians coming to figure out what went wrong.
--From A Fragment on Government--
It's not pretty when such a season ends. You don't have people coming to watch the leaves change colors, you have historians coming to figure out what went wrong.
Saturday, May 23, 2009
Predictions, 1776 edition
The age we live in is a busy age; in which knowledge is rapidly advancing towards perfection.
--From A Fragment on Government--
Reading this you feel like a child riding in the back of a car: "Are we there yet?"
--From A Fragment on Government--
Reading this you feel like a child riding in the back of a car: "Are we there yet?"
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)