data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9ace5/9ace5ee4fa2189112876320a4b7e97db7a8faadc" alt="DSC02173"
The contender: Cappy's Pizza
Style: Deep Dish
In your mouth: With all the sauce and peperoni you'd expect water or oil to drain out of each slice, but the sauce doesn't even move. It's the cleanest pizza I've ever seen:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4eb24/4eb2422ad811840afc4f38fac6990cedb61336e3" alt="A slice of Cappy's Pizza"
So, first you taste astonishment, then jealousy.
For most of the eating experience you can't taste the crust--the sauce dominates. It's rich and savory with a hint of oregano. There could be a bit of red pepper flakes, but the suggestion of "heat" may be from the pepperoni; it's that subtle. The cheese also stands out, it's the flavor you would get from a fried mozzarella stick, but held back a little.
The crust is very delicate, I almost want to call it pastry. I now understand why some people say "pizza pie".
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/04c6c/04c6c4deb8f2208aff1b2aae912afeee84e875d5" alt="Some Cappy's Pizza crust"
It's nice to eat the crust after
The next day: Much more acidic, the cheese flavor has faded and oregano stands out.
Overall: It sounds pretentious to say it was a revelation, but yeah, it was a revelation.